Is social media worth your marketing dollars?

As social media has reached mainstream consciousness this year, businesses have been inundated with the message that they must immediately get on board or risk doom and calamity. The hyperbole (and the frenzied buzz it creates) is confusing and many businesses could use a practical guide on how to evaluate social media and how to engage – if it’s appropriate.facebook-friendfeed

It’s amusing to think that “Word of Mouth” marketing (which, essentially, is what Facebook, Twitter and other social media sites are) is a new phenomenon. Back in the day of low technology and small town America, the only way to pass information was by word of mouth. Neighbors depended on each other for news, including, one can imagine, new products on sale at the local market.

Social communication by “word of mouth” is a fundamental human characteristic and taking advantage of that is fundamental to all marketing because (let’s face it) consumer to consumer (C2C) communication is free.

So the first benefit of using social media in your marketing efforts (and the first thing to keep in mind) is that social media systems are designed to facilitate person-to-person communication, as opposed to traditional media and most first generation web efforts, which are predominately one-way communication.

Social media marketing enables businesses to hear from their customers, observe interaction between customers, enhance trust and build credibility by expanding beyond traditional marketing messages and participate in “communities” with customers.

Small town inhabitants are similar people. Their word of mouth communication is effective for marketers precisely because they have similar tastes and share those tastes with each other. (Usually.)

In other words, they belong to the same market segment.

Market segments are a widely misunderstood concept, frequently equated with verticals, as in “my market segment is the health care industry;” or shared pain (“I am targeting those companies who suffer from email spam”) or a buyer profile (“I am going after college-age kids.”) These criteria may be necessary for a segment, but do not comprise a segment.

Market segments are comprised of like people, who share a common interest, who look to one another as a trusted reference and who have access to each other. If customer in California is just the same as a customer in New York, but they have no means to communicate, they are in separate segments. Your marketing and sales efforts will be developed to reach both geographies.

From a marketing perspective, one of the primary benefits of technological advances has been simplifying communication between like buyers, thereby expanding the reach of market segments. TV, radio, telephone and the Internet have all provided this benefit.

And so it is with social media. Since dial-up bulletin board systems (BBS) first appeared in the late 1970s, users have been “going online” to share common interests.

While early BBS’s were geography-based, today’s descendants, Internet forums, are typically concentrated around a specific hobby or topic independent of geography. Businesses who sell products within these niche markets have long known about these sites, and where welcome, have helped sustain them through advertising dollars.

With North American Internet usage now at 74 percent of the population and the recent proliferation of super-social sites, such as Facebook, LinkedIn, and Twitter, social media has gone mainstream. A broad spectrum of users participates in some Internet social networking activity.

So the second primary benefit of social media is that it can provide a captured audience of customers in your particular target segment.

There are myriad ways of participating in the social media marketing phenomenon. So how can you determine if you should participate and if so, how?

Current activity -First, you should be actively monitoring your brand. Are people talking about you online? Software products exist designed specifically to help you track company and product branding and PR firms often offer this as a service. Minimally, set up Google Alerts to track mentions.

Does online behavior influence purchasing? -Some of your customers may participate in social networking, but their activity may have nothing to do with your product. Tread carefully so as to not intrude on their purpose of participation. (For example, you may wish to advertise on Facebook since you know your customers visit the site, but whether or not to invite them to your fan page requires a more nuanced decision.)

Which social media venues? -As with most things marketing, the answers are with your customers. Where will you find them online? Who influences their buying decisions? Would they find company provided social tools such as online feedback, feature request voting or peer supported forums valuable? Would a company blog enhance credibility, increase trust or loyalty?

Rules of Engagement -Since by and large, consumer participants in online communities determine the rules of engagement for businesses, it’s important that you follow the rules. Your social media activities should not be advertising per se, but rather your participation should provide value to the community. In other words, as a business participant, you are there to share knowledge and expertise to the benefit of the consumer. This is true, by the way, even when you have developed the community.

Social media marketing can be a boon to your company, giving you insight into customers and letting you interact with them in a way few other marketing channels do. Just remember it’s a different world with different rules – and it’s best to be crystal clear on those before you jump in.

———————————————————————-

Come see the most promising new technologies unveiled for the first very time at DEMOfall 09 this September 21-23 in San Diego. VentureBeat readers may register to attend the conference at a special 20% discount off our regular rate. Register now at: http://www.demo.com/f9vb2

Next Story: Sprint to sell Android HTC Hero in October
Previous Story: CrowdEye retools real-time search with CrowdRank

Bookmark and Share

Tags: , , ,

Photo of Brant Cooper

About the Author, Brant Cooper

Brant Cooper possesses over 17 years of success bringing high tech products to market, directing the strategy, design, and launch of key technology offerings by leveraging expertise in technology, marketing, and business development. Brant has served as a Marketing and Product Management executive for several start-ups and currently operates as an independent consultant in San Diego. He blogs about customer development principles and process-oriented, metrics-driven marketing at Market By Numbers.

  • fabeetle
    This was well written though I am not sure it answered the question of "...is it worth your dollars...". Brant did a great job of explaining segments, speaking about adoption and usage, and the intricacies of such vehicles but is it worth your money and more importantly your time?

    This misconception with social media is that you sign up for Facebook, LinkedIn or twitter and something magical happens and you never have to look for a customer again. Not the case obviously. As Brant mentions that social media is simply and extension and digital reflection of something that is core to our being. The desire to connect and share. Social media helps on better visualize how customers are connected, where they build communities, what they do, and more importantly how they talk about your product. Whether that be remote control cars or financial planning. So how does that relate to your marketing dollars?

    First when you spend money, on say a Facebook, advertisement, you are getting a couple of things that are to your advantage over traditional media.

    1. The clients are populating the database with information. As opposed to traditional lists, survey's, etc. that you pay for. When you are using Facebook's tool you are targeting your dollars towards a better quality list. A list that people voluntary update daily. No assumptions, no motivations, no "chance to win a TV if they fill out a quick survey." Per dollar this increases your impact and per unit of time you win because you are not arguing with your list provider or spending time exchanging leads.

    2. You can control your expenditures more by setting budgets and monitoring it daily. With traditional media methods you often incur your expense up front and evaluate at the end of the campaign if it was successful. With Facebook or say Google you can set budgets, wade into the waters, look at your effectiveness on the fly and decide to invest more or hit eject.

    3. Seth Godin speaks of Permission Marketing which is what we are all seeing with these networks. Past communication channels have not offered the level of control that today's channels do. Your email can be sent and sold all over the world, but on Facebook you have to let someone into your "circle of trust" as Dinero would say. Social Media allows you to speak to a customer that is more open to hearing your message because it is at their convenience. Take the same prospect that you may be pursuing. Send them and introductory email at 10am to their office email and it will be sent straight to the trash by their executive assistant that checks their email. Imagine you were able to send that same message to their Facebook mail where they could check in when they are ready to see it. Effectiveness goes up. If you are not their "friend" you can't but you can put it in an add right next to their inbox. Getting closer.

    The above examples speaks to if you are actually committed to spending marketing dollars on social media type advertising. The truth is you can do a lot with free tools as well. Many small business are significantly increasing their reach, image, and customer base by simply combining Facebook, Twitter, a Blog and their website. This can practically be done for free (depending on the website variable). In this case, is it worth your dollars? Absolutely. Is it worth your time? That is a more specific question as it has to do with your product and your customer. If you are selling knitting needles to a 85+ yr old target market...probably not worth your time. You get my point.

    I think to answer the question that was posed in the article, yes, it is "worth" your dollars because for those dollars, if you know what you are doing, you will get higher quality message delivery than other methods. That said, and as I mentioned before, these efforts need to be part of an integrated plan that consistently represents a brand online and off. The consumer still needs to receive your message a couple of times before and a couple of times after a purchase. Social media gives you another, more impactful, more transparent, and more controllable tool to do this.
  • Great article. You hit on some really important points. A lot of business owners hop on board the twitter or facebook trains without really knowing why or what they are doing. Be clear of your objective, know your target market and know how to engage and connect, then the benefits will be seen.
  • I enjoyed reading your very clear and concise article. . I have been helping companies define their segments for years and your definition "..people, who share a common interest, who look to one another as a trusted reference and who have access to each other" is exactly right.
  • businesssocialnetwork
    There are social networks being made that businesses can use to market without spending money. Business social networks, such as www.incompany.com, I feel are more tailored to the needs of businesses that are looking for an effective way to reach prospective customers. I still remain skeptical of business marketing on platforms such as facebook and twitter where the majority of users are not looking to be advertised to.
  • brettharding
    Great article - answers many questions for first-timers that can get caught up in the whole whirlwind of social media.
  • I tend to agree with you on the point that while social media like twitter, facebook, linkedin or orkut are growiing like crazy but they for sure are not yet ready to pay you dividends for your efforts. These are good marketing tools but still need to eveolve to build interactive accountability with in their framework to make this lucrative for marketers and customers both. Let me share some sobering twitter statistics here, that I read somewhere:

    94% of Twitter users have under 100 followers

    90% of tweeting is done by 10% of Twitter users

    60% of new Twitter users fail to return the following month

    50% of Twitter accounts are inactive (haven't tweeted in the past week)

    40% of tweets are "pointless babble"

    35% of Twitter users have 10 or fewer followers

    21% of Twitter accounts are empty placeholders

    11% of Twitter users interact with brands on Twitter

    9% of Twitter users don't follow anyone at all

    3% of followers click on links tweeted